WORD REIMAGINED The wire · 38 filed · live

Source archive Tier A

Journal of the Proceedings of the Constitutional Convention of the State of Mississippi (1890)

Mississippi. Constitutional Convention (1890), Journal of the Proceedings of the Constitutional Convention of the State of Mississippi. Jackson, Miss.: E. L. Martin, 1890. 757 pp. Convention called under an Act approved February 5, 1890; delegates elected July 29, 1890, per the proclamation of Governor John M. Stone reproduced at p. 5. Read from the Internet Archive scan (digitized by Google from the University of Michigan copy), full text `journalproceedi01convgoog_djvu.txt`.

Custody docket

Record
ms-constitutional-convention-journal-1890
Type
archive
Trust tier
A
Status
published

Sources are graded A (primary) / B (secondary academic) / C (secondary journalism) / D (tertiary or contested). See the manifesto’s Evidence Standard for full criteria.

The official record of the convention that disenfranchised Black Mississippi, and it places Isaiah T. Montgomery inside the committee that did it.

Full text pulled and searched directly, 2.1 MB, 172 occurrences of “Montgomery” reviewed in place rather than counted. Note the surname is also a Mississippi county and another delegate’s name (Montgomery — J. R. Binford), so a raw count is not a finding. Both facts below were read in context.

1. He was seated for Bolivar County

From the roll of delegates by county:

“Bolivar — G. P. Melchior, I. T. Montgomery.”

Bolivar County is Mound Bayou’s county. Isaiah Montgomery, whom the 1975 nomination calls one of “the two co-founders,” sat in this convention as one of its two delegates.

2. He sat on the Committee on Elective Franchise

This is the load-bearing fact, and it is stronger than any account of what he said. The committee roster, as printed:

“Elective Franchise, Apportionment and Elections — Messrs. Patty, George, Alcorn, Martin, of Adams; Powel, Magruder, Hudson, Burkitt, McLean, of Grenada; Lester, Richards, Allen, Blair, Boyd, McNeily Boothe, Simonton, Dean, McClurg, Hooker, Morgan, Reagan, of Newton; McGehee, of Wilkinson; Carter, Binford, Bell, Street, Harris, Guyton, Puryear, Reynolds, Robinson, of Union; Watson, Regan, of Claiborn; and Montgomery.”

He is listed last, after the semicolon, alone. The sole Black delegate was placed on the committee that wrote the franchise article. (The Journal prints no delegate’s race; “the lone black delegate” is from mississippi-encyclopedia-constitution-of-1890, added 2026-10-02.)

Corrected 2026-10-02: this roster printed “Resan,” which exists only in the Internet Archive’s machine-read text. The printed page 22, read in the page image, sets “Regan,” and the Journal’s roll of delegates prints “Claiborne — C. K. Regan.”

3. What the Journal also shows him doing

At the procedural stage he offered a resolution, printed in full:

“Resolved, That every proposition or amendment to the Constitution shall be referred to the proper Committee without debate.”

A substitute by Mr. Muldrow displaced it and was itself amended and referred to the Committee on Rules. It did not carry in his form. The rules the Convention adopted the same day, August 15, 1890, carry the same idea. Rule XLII, printed page 48: “Every resolution or ordinance on a subject upon which there is a standing committee, shall be referred to the appropriate committee without debate, and no final action shall be had upon such resolution until the committee shall have reported thereon …” (the rule continues).

On September 26 the Journal prints him presenting “an instrument from the Board of Supervisors of Bolivar County,” a memorial asking that the Constitution provide “a just and fair tax, to be levied on railroads now built, or hereafter to be built in the Delta” (printed page 284; referred to the Committee on Corporations). The memorial came “through its President Mr. E. H. Moore”; an E. H. Moore of Bolivar is also the first-named contestant for Montgomery’s seat. This record does not say they are the same man.

His seat was contested. Printed page 67 (page image): the Select Committee on “the contested election case, from the county of Bolivar, of E. H. Moore, and W. L. Pearman, contestants, vs. George P. Melchior and Isaiah T. Montgomery contestees, submitted a majority and a minority report.” On page 79, Mr. Dillard raised a point of order “that under Rule 42, adopted by the Convention that no debate could be had on propositions, amendments, resolutions etc., proposing to amend the Constitution”; “The point of order was sustained by the President.”

Corrected 2026-10-02: this section called the resolution “his one recorded motion in this stretch” and stopped at its failure. The Journal records the rule that carried its idea and a second act of his on the record.

🔴 WHAT THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT

This is a Journal, not a record of debates. It records motions, referrals, rosters and votes. It does not contain Isaiah Montgomery’s August 1890 speech, and no part of that speech may be quoted or characterized from this record.

The speech is reported to have been printed in the New York World in September 1890 and is said to be anthologized in a Matthew Holden Jr. volume titled “What Answer?” (2004). No catalog searched on 2026-10-02 lists that title, and the source that named it was not read, so the title is not cited. Neither has been obtained. Until one is read, the essay may state that he sat on the franchise committee — which this document proves — and may not state what he argued, which it does not.

⚠️ OCR caveats. The scan carries artifacts (Claiborn, McNeily Boothe without a comma, Resan for Reagan/Regan, sliall, tlie). Corrected 2026-10-02: §2 now follows the printed page image (“Regan”), not the scan; the other quotations above were taken from the scan. Any quotation lifted from this file must be re-read in place, and a clean printed edition should be consulted before anything from it reaches print.


🔴 2026-09-22 — RE-READ IN PLACE. All three facts reproduce. One transcription above does not.

The scan was pulled again (journalproceedi01convgoog_djvu.txt, 2,110,062 bytes) and each quotation located by line rather than trusted. Findings:

  • The Bolivar roll (§1) reproduces, at line 222: Bolivar — G. P. Melchior, I. T. Montgomery.
  • The Elective Franchise roster (§2) reproduces (except “Resan,” which the printed page 22 sets as “Regan”; corrected 2026-10-02), at lines 1294–1301, and and Montgomery. is the last entry, alone after the semicolon, exactly as recorded. (The scan prints Wilkinson ; with a space before the semicolon; §2 above closes it up. Whitespace only.)
  • The resolution (§3) reproduces in substance and is correctly attributed — line 1955 reads Mr. Montgomery offered the following resolution : — but the transcription above is not what the scan says.

The scan, lines 1957–1959, exactly:

Resolved, That every proposition or amendment to the / Constitution sliall be referred to tlie proper Committee with- / out debate.

§3 above prints this as “shall be referred to the proper Committee without debate.” — sliall silently expanded to shall, tlie to the. This record’s own OCR caveat names sliall and tlie as artifacts and then prints a cleaned quotation two sections above it, under a heading that says quotations “preserve the scan exactly.” ⭐⭐ A CAVEAT NAMING AN ARTIFACT DOES NOT LICENSE THE QUOTATION THAT REMOVES IT.

The distinction that governs, and it is not the same as the “maleria” case. maleria is the document’s spelling — the 1975 NRHP form was typed that way, so reproducing it is reproducing the record. sliall is the scanner’s failure to read a word the 1890 printer set correctly. Reproducing an OCR artifact as though the convention wrote it would be its own fabrication.

🔴 THE RULE FOR ANY ESSAY DRAWING ON THIS RECORD: do not quote the corrupted stretch at all. Quote only the clean words — without debate is clean in the scan — and state the rest of the motion in the essay’s own voice. A clean printed edition must be consulted before the full sentence is ever quoted.

What the motion was, stated and not quoted: Montgomery moved that every proposition or amendment to the Constitution be referred to the proper committee without debate, with a further clause letting that committee send the matter back for printing before its final report. Mr. Muldrow offered a substitute; Mr. Dillard amended the substitute; the substitute as amended went to the Committee on Rules. His motion did not carry in his form.

Provenance

Creator
Mississippi. Constitutional Convention (1890)
Published
1890
Accessed
2026-07-31

Cited by

Theme custody

No theme record references this source.