Source archive Tier D
RETIRED — Church of Lukumi Babalu Aye v. City of Hialeah (1993), duplicate record
RETIRED 2026-07-14. Superseded by lukumi-babalu-aye-v-hialeah-1993, which is built from the bound United States Reports and carries verbatim text. This record is preserved for audit only and must not be cited.
Custody docket
- Record
- lukumi-v-hialeah-1993
- Type
- archive
- Trust tier
- D
- Status
- archived
Sources are graded A (primary) / B (secondary academic) / C (secondary journalism) / D (tertiary or contested). See the manifesto’s Evidence Standard for full criteria.
RETIRED. Do not cite. Superseded by lukumi-babalu-aye-v-hialeah-1993.
Preserved, not deleted, per standing doctrine: retire is preserve-and-supersede.
This was a duplicate record for the same case. It carried no verbatim text, and its one substantive sentence contained the error that got it retired. It said the ordinances were:
“drafted for the purpose of suppressing Santería worship”
Purpose is the one word two Justices refused to sign. Scalia, joined by Rehnquist, expressly declined to join the section of the opinion addressing legislative motive, because it “departs from the opinion’s general focus on the object of the laws at issue to consider the subjective motivation of the lawmakers.”
All nine signed object. Two of nine declined purpose. A record asserting a unanimous finding of purpose overstates the Court by exactly two votes, and it was cited by the published anchor essay for six weeks.
The surviving record quotes the bound volume and preserves the distinction.
NOTE (2026-07-15): primary repointed from Justia to the LOC bound volume — U.S. Reports: Church of Lukumi Babalu Aye, Inc. v. City of Hialeah, 508 U.S. 520 (1993), https://www.loc.gov/item/usrep508520/ (verified HTTP 200; PDF at tile.loc.gov/…/usrep508520.pdf). The LOC bound volume is the corrected edition; earlier Justia-sourced text carried an ‘eastern Africa’ rendering the bound volume gives as ‘western’. The Justia URL 403s to automated fetchers.
NOTE (2026-10-02): the vote count above is wrong. Per the joining line in the bound volume’s syllabus, the holding on object (Parts II-A-1 and II-A-3) was joined by five Justices, not nine, and the section on legislative motive (Part II-A-2) by two, Kennedy and Stevens; seven did not join it. All nine joined the judgment. The text above is preserved as written; the live record lukumi-babalu-aye-v-hialeah-1993 carries the correct count.
Provenance
- Creator
- Supreme Court of the United States
- Published
- 1993
- Accessed
- 2026-07-14
- External record
- https://www.loc.gov/item/usrep508520/
Cited by
No published file currently cites this source.
Theme custody
No theme record references this source.